Skip to content

Could Germany Have Realistically Won Ww2

As we celebrate the ending of the war 75 years ago, know this: victory for the Allies was never guaranteed, and historians agree there were countless ways Germany could have won the war. Defeat never came down to one battle or one campaign.

The answer has to be ‘yes’ but with conditions. Those conditions include the element of luck, which no commander can ignore, as well as the vision of those involved. Had Hitler possessed a strategic maritime vision to match that of Dönitz, then Germany would have had a greater chance of victory.

Hitler’s air force could have won a pivotal World War II battle if it had attacked earlier and changed tactics, a study says. Between May and October 1940, the German Luftwaffe fought British-led fighter pilots – including Australians – over the skies of southern England in the Battle of Britain.

Outside Britain, Europeans tend to say it was the United States that contributed most to winning WWII – and relatively few credit the USSR. Next week will mark the 70th anniversary of VE day, the day Nazi Germany officially surrendered in the Second World War.

Could Germany have won the battle of the Atlantic?

It is conceivable, for instance, that Imperial Germany may have won the Battle of the Atlantic—the U-boats’ effort to sever sea routes connecting beleaguered Great Britain with North America—had it done certain basic homework.

What was Hitler’s last chance to win the war?

WWII History: The Battle of the Bulge – Hitler’s Last Chance to Win World War 2 – World War Two – WW2.

Could Germany have won the Battle of Britain?

Hitler’s air force could have won a pivotal World War II battle if it had attacked earlier and changed tactics, a study says. Between May and October 1940, the German Luftwaffe fought British-led fighter pilots – including Australians – over the skies of southern England in the Battle of Britain.

Who is most responsible for winning WW2?

Outside Britain, Europeans tend to say it was the United States that contributed most to winning WWII – and relatively few credit the USSR.

Could the Germans won the Battle of the Atlantic?

It is conceivable, for instance, that Imperial Germany may have won the Battle of the Atlantic—the U-boats’ effort to sever sea routes connecting beleaguered Great Britain with North America—had it done certain basic homework.

Why did Germany fail to win the Battle of the Atlantic?

Hitler had lost the Battle of the Atlantic, due the perseverance of individual sailors and merchant seamen who kept the ships moving no matter what, along with improved coordination between the British Navy and Air Force, and technological developments that tipped the scales in favor of the Allies.

Could Germany win the battle of the bulge?

The Battle of the Bulge marked the last German offense on the Western Front. The catastrophic losses on the German side prevented Germany from resisting the advance of Allied forces following the Normandy Invasion. Less than four months after the end of the Battle of the Bulge, Germany surrendered to Allied forces.

Could Germany won the Battle of Britain?

Luftwaffe ‘could have won Battle of Britain if they attacked earlier,’ new study suggests. Germany’s Luftwaffe could have won the Battle of Britain if they had attacked earlier and focused on bombing airfields, a new study has suggested.

What was Germany’s last chance to win ww2?

In the Second Half of 1942, Nazi Germany Fumbled Its Last Chance to Win World War II…

What was Hitler’s last gamble to win the war?

16, 1944, was brazen. The Wehrmacht hoped to smash through the Allied lines near the Ardennes Forest in Belgium and advance several hundred miles to the Atlantic coast. The blitz was a gamble, based on Hitler’s belief that even though the Allies had superior manpower, he would have the initiative.

What was Hitler’s last victory?

Yet Germany nearly captured Paris in 1914, crushed Serbia and Romania, bled the French Army until it mutinied, drove Russia out of the war, and then came oh-so-close to victory on the Western Front in 1918.

What would happen if Germany won the Battle of Britain?

The most likely result of German victory and the success of Operation Sea Lion would have been a new government in the UK. During the Battle of Britain, the skies above the United Kingdom were the battlefield between the Royal Air Force (RAF) and the Luftwaffe.

Could Germany have won the Battle of Britain Reddit?

The only way that Germany could have ever hoped to defeat Britain was complete, uncontested dominance of battlespace in both air and sea. While losing air superiority is plausible, they would have had to lose naval superiority for the Germans to even think about a successful invasion.

Why did Germany lose the Battle of Britain?

The decisive factors were British capability and determination, but German mistakes, before and during the battle, contributed significantly to the outcome. German rearmament was forbidden by the Treaty of Versailles at the end of World War I, but aircraft development continued under the guise of civil aviation.

Who was responsible for victory in ww2?

Although the Soviet, British, American and Canadian armies together defeated Germany, Hitler’s flawed decision making played a significant role in the Allied victory in Europe.

Who is the most important person in winning ww2?

The total man power available to Allies from Russia and America was far greater than the limited manpower of Germany and Japan. The military production of the Allies far exceeded the production of the Axis, even without the large loses of military production due to Allie bombing.

More Answers On Could Germany Have Realistically Won Ww2

Did Germany Ever Stand a Chance of Winning WW2?

-New Technology (1943-45): It is often said that the Germans relied too heavily on the idea that a new generation of “Wonder Weapons” would win them the war. And a lot of resources were wasted on such colossal failures like the Me 163 Komet and the 188 ton Maus super tank. German Volkssturm Marching with Panzerfausts in Berlin 1944.

Fact: Adolf Hitler Could Have Won World War II

Even with everything noted above, Germany and its European partners could have still won the war were it not for Germany’s declaration of war on the United States on December 11, 1941. It was…

Could the Germans have ever realistically won ww2? | Fandom

Sameva555 · 12/8/2013 in Questions and Answers Could the Germans have ever realistically won ww2? i think if you ever did want to have a non asb scenario it would have to have a pod before the war, from 1939 onwards the germans could never win the war, just prolonge it. what does everyone else think? (edited by Sameva555) 0 55 VIEW OLDER REPLIES 0

What if Germany won WW2? – viatravelers.com

Based on the Leader Principle, all Nazi client states would defer to Germany, as done under German occupation during WW2. In The Man in the High Castle, there’s growing discontent between the two erstwhile allies, as Germany advances and grows technologically and militarily, while Japan’s growth is hindered by her ties to traditionalism.

If Germany had won World War II, how long would the Third Reich … – Quora

There was an answer on Quora from someone much wiser than me that basically asserted that Germany did win WWII — *. Conquered all of Western Europe *. Drove the U.K. out of the Continent. But then they got too ambitious and messed it all up…. With declaring war on the U.S., Russia and all.

What would have happened if Germany had won WWII? – Quora

November 15, 1941. Moscow, USSR. The German 3rd Panzer Group is 87 miles from the Kremlin. Martial law is declared in the city of Moscow. The snow, sleet, and bitter temperatures have prevented Nazi Germany from further attacking the capital. Still, things are grim for Joseph Stalin.

Germany should (militarily) have won WW2 | SpaceBattles

There is next to no chance that Germany was going to win the Second World War. 78 lackofgravitas all this will soon be lost like ducks in the rain Aug 5, 2021 #3 There was no way the Nazi Germany could knock the UK out of the fight never had enough u boats never had enough planes oppenhimers hammer would arrive at some point

Could Germany have won WW2? : NoStupidQuestions

It would be nearly impossible for Germany to win WWII, not against the constellation of forces that opposed them. The US and the USSR had huge advantages in production capabilities and sheer available manpower. They would have been able to bleed Germany dry no matter who was in charge of the country.

If Hitler Had Won World War II We’d Have A Better, More Just World …

The rest of the world would have similarly benefited had the Germans been victorious since German influence would have surely spread elsewhere (ideas such as non-usurious banking and strong family oriented culture would likely have spread globally). Had Hitler won World War II, what would be different in the post-war world? Here are a few examples:

15 Catastrophic Things That Would Have Happened If Hitler Had Won

If Germany won World War II and became a world superpower, no doubt they’d eventually use cameras, microphones and other spy materials to make sure the citizens were always behaving. Think: George Orwell’s 1984. 10. Hitler’s Face Would Be Everywhere.

How Nazi Germany Could Have Crushed Russia During World War II

In this article, we shall examine how Germany might have not only avoided total defeat at the hands of the Red Army, but even might have achieved a measure of victory against her much larger and…

Facts: Could Germany really have won World War II

So, based on the above, could Germany have realistically won World War II? I think to answer that you have to look at the various powers it was facing after the Fall of France in 1940 and whether or not it could have defeated them. United Kingdom (including the British Empire)

Could Germany, realistically, could have won World War I?

TL;DR: Realistically no, at least not in the format that WWI happened in OTL. They could win a different, smaller European conflict but one the size and scope of WWI is very unlikely. level 1 · 5 mo. ago Germany could have won a war in Europe. If they could have won a war on the scale of WWI is unlikely.

World War II: What would have happened if Germany had invaded the U.S.?

The Germans would have faced an armed force at least 10 times the size of their invasion force, who were also motivated to ensure that they (the Germans) would lose. The Germans also still would …

How could Nazi Germany have won WW2? – SpaceBattles

By not starting WW2. Germany was a regional power. A strong one for sure, but it tried to bite off far more than it could chew. You want germany to come out on top you have to do an effective rearmment, have the secret service on your side and not work for the enemy, don’t have massive infighting and the ability to keep your war industry running.

Did Germany fail to win WW2 because they did not fight hard … – Quora

The Soviets most likely could have beaten Germany without help from England (in 1941) or the opening of a second front (in 1944) but it would have taken much, much longer – probably at least a couple of years and maybe longer. … Realistically though the course of the war doesn’t change. Soviet wartime production isn’t impacted enough to …

What Would the World be Like if Germany Won WWI?

One thing that could be said if Germany won in the end. The country would have imposed peace on the defeated allies at the treaty of Potsdam, and it would not have had the reparations and grievances that were generally inflicted by France and Versailles. As a consequence, the rise of Hitler would have been less likely.

Nazi Germany – Wikipedia

Nazi Germany, officially known as the German Reich from 1933 until 1943, and the Greater German Reich from 1943 to 1945, was the German state between 1933 and 1945, when Adolf Hitler and the Nazi Party controlled the country, transforming it into a dictatorship.Under Hitler’s rule, Germany quickly became a totalitarian state where nearly all aspects of life were controlled by the government.

How did America win the battle of Midway? – Meltingpointathens.com

Could Germany have realistically won ww2? As we celebrate the ending of the war 75 years ago, know this: victory for the Allies was never guaranteed, and historians agree there were countless ways Germany could have won the war. Defeat never came down to one battle or one campaign. Did America bomb Japan after Pearl Harbour?

Question: Why did the united states enter world war 2?

Sooner or later, these sinking would have forced FDR’s hand to declare war on Germany. Could Germany have realistically won ww2? As we celebrate the ending of the war 75 years ago, know this: victory for the Allies was never guaranteed, and historians agree there were countless ways Germany could have won the war.

Could Germany have won WW2? | Overclockers UK Forums

Could Germany have won WW2? Thread starter nightrider1470; … Realistically if they hadn’t had a madman in charge they would have been at the negotiating table in 41. 12 Nov 2017 #20 dbmzk1. dbmzk1. Soldato. Joined 28 Oct 2002 Posts 9,227 Location Stockport / Manchester.

How could the germans have won WW1 after 1917?

Of the OTL fourteen points, Germany could have agreed to most of them and still be considered to have come out on top: No secret treaties. Germany could accept this without much problem. Freedom of the seas. This is actively to Germany’s advantage, given the British starvation blockade was one of the Allies’ most powerful weapons against Germany.

What Weapons Do The French Foreign Legion Use? – Cursor Web

Could Germany have realistically won ww2? There is no definitive answer to this question as it pertains to Germany’s realistically possibility in the ww2. It is possible that different factors could have led to a different outcome, such as a superior economy or military, had the war been more contestible. …

Facts: Could Germany really have won World War II

So, based on the above, could Germany have realistically won World War II? I think to answer that you have to look at the various powers it was facing after the Fall of France in 1940 and whether or not it could have defeated them. United Kingdom (including the British Empire)

Could Germany have won WW2? | Overclockers UK Forums

Could Germany have won WW2? Thread starter nightrider1470; … Realistically if they hadn’t had a madman in charge they would have been at the negotiating table in 41. 12 Nov 2017 #20 dbmzk1. dbmzk1. Soldato. Joined 28 Oct 2002 Posts 9,227 Location Stockport / Manchester.

Did Germany fail to win WW2 because they did not fight hard … – Quora

The Soviets most likely could have beaten Germany without help from England (in 1941) or the opening of a second front (in 1944) but it would have taken much, much longer – probably at least a couple of years and maybe longer. … Realistically though the course of the war doesn’t change. Soviet wartime production isn’t impacted enough to …

Germany could have WON the Battle of Britain if they started earlier

The study suggests that if Germany had launched an attack in June following Winston Churchill’s (pictured) famous Battle of Britain’ speech and targeted airfields, the Nazis would have probably …

What would have happened if Hitler won WWII? – Funadvice

Answer #3. well first of all, it wouldn’t have been all three of those countries to have won. you have to think about who their respective leaders were and how each of them had acted prior towards other countries. especially hitler, who betrayed all of his alliances with countries and broke treaties. its more realistic to think germany would’ve …

Could the US have defeated Germany alone in WW2 – Historum

Mar 21, 2015. #5. No nation could have defeated Germany alone in WWII. Without Britain our coasts would have probably fell prey to U-boats and we would have no means to leverage our industrial might into Europe, without the SU absorbing most of the Axis ground strength a land invasion would be unfeasible. Reactions:

Could the Germans have taken Moscow? « Isegoria

Because the Germans have better troops and commanders in 1941, they can chew up the Soviet armies, forcing the Soviets to hastily commit unprepared reserves, which in turn get destroyed in a vicious cycle. […] Compared to the lavishly equipped U.S. Army of World War II, the German and Soviet armies faced a logistical nightmare.

Resource

https://www.warhistoryonline.com/instant-articles/nazi-germany-winning-ww2.html
https://nationalinterest.org/blog/buzz/fact-adolf-hitler-could-have-won-world-war-ii-151411
https://althistory.fandom.com/f/p/2100587873173944603
https://viatravelers.com/what-if-germany-won-ww2/
https://www.quora.com/If-Germany-had-won-World-War-II-how-long-would-the-Third-Reich-realistically-have-lasted?share=1
https://www.quora.com/What-would-have-happened-if-Germany-had-won-WWII?share=1
https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/germany-should-militarily-have-won-ww2.956599/
https://www.reddit.com/r/NoStupidQuestions/comments/lblwai/could_germany_have_won_ww2/
https://nationalvanguard.org/2017/01/if-hitler-won-world-war-ii-wed-have-a-better-more-just-world-today/
https://www.theclever.com/15-catastrophic-things-that-would-have-happened-if-hitler-had-won/
https://nationalinterest.org/blog/buzz/how-nazi-germany-could-have-crushed-russia-during-world-war-ii-82481
https://alternate-timelines.com/thread/769/facts-germany-won-world-war
https://www.reddit.com/r/AlternateHistory/comments/qdvib8/could_germany_realistically_could_have_won_world/
https://slate.com/human-interest/2015/08/world-war-ii-what-would-have-happened-if-germany-had-invaded-the-u-s.html
https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/how-could-nazi-germany-have-won-ww2.326436/
https://germanyandgermans.quora.com/Did-Germany-fail-to-win-WW2-because-they-did-not-fight-hard-smart-fast-enough-use-every-single-man-tank-ship-pla?share=1
https://www.warhistoryonline.com/war-articles/germany-won.html
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazi_Germany
https://www.meltingpointathens.com/how-did-america-win-the-battle-of-midway/
https://www.caagesf.org/faq/question-why-did-the-united-states-enter-world-war-2.html
https://forums.overclockers.co.uk/threads/could-germany-have-won-ww2.18799692/
https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/how-could-the-germans-have-won-ww1-after-1917.329734/
https://cursorweb.com/what-weapons-do-the-french-foreign-legion-use/
https://alternate-timelines.com/thread/769/facts-germany-won-world-war
https://forums.overclockers.co.uk/threads/could-germany-have-won-ww2.18799692/
https://germanyandgermans.quora.com/Did-Germany-fail-to-win-WW2-because-they-did-not-fight-hard-smart-fast-enough-use-every-single-man-tank-ship-pla?share=1
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-7872831/Germany-WON-Battle-Britain-started-earlier-study-finds.html
https://www.funadvice.com/q/what_would_have_happened_if_hitler
https://historum.com/threads/could-the-us-have-defeated-germany-alone-in-ww2.87189/
https://www.isegoria.net/2021/07/could-the-germans-have-taken-moscow/