As Carthage valued gold overpower, they likely would have left Gaul, Germany, and Britannia intact, preferring to use them as political allies and trading partners. Therefore, Northern Europe would have continued to develop as independent states and maintained their pagan heritage.
This weakness allowed the wiser Roman commanders (Fabius’ plan) sap Hannibal’s manpower, which was mixed between Carthaginians and mercenaries. Although Hannibal kept winning battles and inflicting heavy casualties, he could not win the war because he did not have enough men.
Could Carthage have won 3rd Punic War?
As Carthage valued gold overpower, they likely would have left Gaul, Germany, and Britannia intact, preferring to use them as political allies and trading partners. Therefore, Northern Europe would have continued to develop as independent states and maintained their pagan heritage.
Can Carthage win during the Punic Wars?
This weakness allowed the wiser Roman commanders (Fabius’ plan) sap Hannibal’s manpower, which was mixed between Carthaginians and mercenaries. Although Hannibal kept winning battles and inflicting heavy casualties, he could not win the war because he did not have enough men.
What if Carthage won the Third Punic War?
As Carthage valued gold overpower, they likely would have left Gaul, Germany, and Britannia intact, preferring to use them as political allies and trading partners. Therefore, Northern Europe would have continued to develop as independent states and maintained their pagan heritage.
Can Carthage win?
They couldn’t have won the second or third Punic Wars but they might have been able to win the first one. The Romans won the first one due to the lucky break of a Carthaginian ship washing up on Italian soil intact. The Romans had no warships or knowledge of building them or using them.
Could Hannibal have won the Punic Wars?
This weakness allowed the wiser Roman commanders (Fabius’ plan) sap Hannibal’s manpower, which was mixed between Carthaginians and mercenaries. Although Hannibal kept winning battles and inflicting heavy casualties, he could not win the war because he did not have enough men.
Could Carthage have won the 2nd Punic War?
Had Carthage acted on Hannibal’s requests, the Second Punic War could have ended with a Carthaginian victory over Rome. Instead, they sent only as much aid as would not inconvenience them and Hannibal had no choice but to fight those battles which he felt he could win.
Did Carthage win any of the Punic Wars?
The three Punic Wars between Carthage and Rome took place over nearly a century, beginning in 264 B.C. and ending in Roman victory with the destruction of Carthage in 146 B.C. By the time the First Punic War broke out, Rome had become the dominant power throughout the Italian peninsula, while Carthage–a powerful city- …
How did Carthage lose the Punic Wars?
Carthage was beginning to lose control of its empire. Instead of risk another war, Carthage was forced to agree that Rome could control the territories of Sardinia and Corsica, and pay another fine. Many Carthaginians were outraged by the defeat and humiliation over Sardinia and wanted revenge.
How was Carthage defeated?
In 147 bce, the Roman senate sent a new commander, Scipio Aemilianus, with orders to take the city by storm. He defeated the Carthaginian field army and built a mole to block the city’s harbor. The end came in the spring of 146 bce after the besiegers made a breach in the city walls.
What advantages did Carthage have in the Punic Wars?
Its coffers paid for mercenaries in abundance when the city needed to go to war. The Carthaginians had the advantage in skill and numbers at sea. Hannibal was able to adapt and turn the Romans advantages against them, but other Carthaginian commanders just didnxe2u20ac™t have the skill.
Who would win the 3 Punic Wars Rome or Carthage?
The three Punic Wars between Carthage and Rome took place over nearly a century, beginning in 264 B.C. and ending in Roman victory with the destruction of Carthage in 146 B.C. By the time the First Punic War broke out, Rome had become the dominant power throughout the Italian peninsula, while Carthage–a powerful city- …
What if Rome lost to Carthage?
In 146 BC the Romans stormed the city of Carthage, sacked it, slaughtered most of its population and completely demolished it. The previously Carthaginian territories were taken over as the Roman province of Africa. The ruins of the city lie 16 kilometres (10 mi) east of modern Tunis on the North African coast.
What would be the result of the 3rd Punic war what would happen to Carthage and its citizens?
Third Punic War, also called Third Carthaginian War, (149–146 bce), third of three wars between the Roman Republic and the Carthaginian (Punic) Empire that resulted in the final destruction of Carthage, the enslavement of its population, and Roman hegemony over the western Mediterranean.
What would happen if Carthage won?
As Carthage valued gold overpower, they likely would have left Gaul, Germany, and Britannia intact, preferring to use them as political allies and trading partners. Therefore, Northern Europe would have continued to develop as independent states and maintained their pagan heritage.
Could Hannibal have won the war?
Article. Hannibal Barca (l. 247-183 BCE), the brilliant Carthaginian general of the Second Punic War (218-202 BCE), had the military talent, expertise, and skill to have won the conflict but was denied the resources by his government.
What if Hannibal won the Punic War?
His well-planned strategies allowed him to conquer and ally with several Italian cities that were previously allied to Rome. Hannibal occupied most of southern Italy for 15 years. The Romans, led by Fabius Maximus, avoided heavy confrontation with him, instead waging a war of attrition.
More Answers On Could Carthage Have Won The Punic Wars
Could Carthage have won the Punic Wars? – AskingLot.com
Could Carthage have won the Punic Wars? First Punic War: Yes. The FPW was mostly a naval war and Carthage was the main naval power of the Western Mediterranean at that time, Rome had no navy before the war, so Carthage could win this one by cutting off the Roman armies in Sicily from reinforcements from mainland Italy. Click to see full answer.
What if Carthage had won the Punic Wars? – Classical Wisdom Weekly
The Punic wars would have ended early, Carthage would have colonized Italy and gone on to become the dominant superpower in the Mediterranean, significantly altering European history as we know it. Hannibal’s celebrated feat in Crossing the Alps Fresco. Jacopo Ripanda c. 1510 Geography and Borders
Could Carthage have won the Punic Wars? : history – reddit
Carthage could have won in the first or second punic wars if its noble and wealthy families had put more into the war effort, and if it hadn’t relied so heavily on mercenaries. Rome ended up being much more willing to engage in ’total war’ however.
What If Carthage Won the Punic Wars? | Mind Revolt
What If Carthage Won the Punic Wars? The world we know today would have never existed. by Mario Bou Debes November 26, 2018 in History To read this article in Arabic, click here. Wars of the titans… Two mighty super powers inevitably clashing for the dominance of the Mediterranean…
Could the Carthaginians have won the Punic wars against Rome? What …
They couldn’t have won the second or third Punic Wars but they might have been able to win the first one. The Romans won the first one due to the lucky break of a Carthaginian ship washing up on Italian soil intact. The Romans had no warships or knowledge of building them or using them.
濫 Could Carthage have won the Punic Wars?
Could Carthage have won the Punic Wars? First Punic War : Yes. The FPW was mostly a naval war and Carthage was the main naval power of the Western Mediterranean at that time, Rome had no navy before the war , so Carthage could win this one by cutting off the Roman armies in Sicily from reinforcements from mainland Italy.
Punic Wars – Definition, Who Fought & Who Won – HISTORY
Background and First Punic War (264-241 B.C.) Second Punic War (218-201 B.C.) Third Punic War (149-146 B.C.) The three Punic Wars between Carthage and Rome took place over nearly a century,…
WI: Carthage wins the Punic Wars | alternatehistory.com
Carthage simply did not have the manpower to throw at the enemy. To make Carthage truly conquer Rome, you need more manpower for Carthage. Carthaginians relying on mercenaries was not just for fun, or sheer obstinacy. They needed mercenaries just to be able to field a reasonably large army. Jun 2, 2013.
What would the world look like today if Carthage had won the Punic Wars?
If Carthage won the first Punic War there would be no real change to the timeline – Carthage had won and lost battles with the Greek powers in Sicily for centuries and didn’t really make too much of a fuss. Carthage would win, then forget about it and keep trading (which is what they really wanted). Rome on the other hand wouldn’t forget.
The Punic Wars: How did the Romans crush Carthage?
The Romans burned down the ruins of the city, Carthage was leveled to the ground, and cursed in a special ceremony, prohibiting its settlement. Thus, in 120 years, Rome crushed Carthage’s pursuits of domination. As it turned out, the Punic Wars marked the emergence of Roman imperial rule, which eventually swept the world.
Could Carthage Have Won The Punic Wars? [Comprehensive Answer]
The FPW was mostly a naval war and Carthage was the main naval power of the Western Mediterranean at that time, Rome had no navy before the war , so Carthage could win this one by cutting off the Roman armies in Sicily from reinforcements from mainland Italy. Rome and Carthage fought the the three wars known as the Punic Wars because the first …
4 Reasons Hannibal Couldn’t Win the War for Carthage
Rome had won the first Punic War by simply outlasting the Carthaginians in men and resources. The Romans had a potential manpower pool of around 700,000 men and were determined to win total victory no matter the cost. Hannibal knew that invading Italy was his best chance.
If Carthage won the Punic Wars? | Paradox Interactive Forums
If Carthage won the Punic Wars? Thread starter Imperator1993; Start date Jul 25, 2012; Jump to latest Follow Reply Menu . 1; 2; 3; Next. 1 of 3 Go to page. Go. Next … If you can see any way that Carthage could have survived long enough to develop seafaring ships then please explain.
What if Carthage won the punic wars : HistoryWhatIf – reddit
In short, unlike the first war, Carthage’s only way to win this war is to defeat Rome AND its (by now much larger) empire. Oh, and it would have to be achieved before the likes of Scipio sneak off to attack Iberia. Unlikely, but were Carthage successful, Rome would have ceased to exist as anything other than a local force within years.
The Punic Wars Part III | “Delenda Cartago est” – The Kosmos Society
The third stage of the Punic Wars was by far the shortest, lasting from 149-146 BCE, and was entirely fought in Africa, resulting in the destruction of Carthage. The decades following the Second Punic War saw the Carthaginians regain prosperity, while the Romans engaged in nearly continuous warfare in Spain, Gaul, and Macedonia. [2]
Ancient Carthage – Wikipedia
Carthage (/ ˈ k ɑːr θ ɪ dʒ /) was a settlement in modern Tunisia that later became a city-state and then an empire. Founded by the Phoenicians in the ninth century BC, it was destroyed by the Romans in 146 BC, who later rebuilt the city lavishly. At its height in the fourth century BC, Carthage was one of the largest metropolises in the world, and the centre of the Carthaginian Empire, a …
If Carthage won the Punic Wars? | Page 2 | Paradox Interactive Forums
So to summarise the results of Carthage winning the Punic Wars, it is my opinion that Carthage could have possibly have had heralded a new age for the ancient world. An age of trade and development. 5. Reactions: Reply. Report. yerm. Field Marshal. 67 Badges.
who won the 3rd punic war – Top Tips
13 Who initiated the Third Punic War quizlet? 14 Did Rome win all the Punic Wars? 15 Who beat the Romans? 16 Why was the Roman army so successful? 17 Are Greeks Carthaginians? 18 What race are Carthaginians? 19 Are Tunisians Carthaginians? 20 What if Carthage won the Third Punic War? 21 What was the result of Punic Wars? 22 How did Rome defeat …
The Fall Of Carthage The Punic Wars 265 146bc Cassell Military Paperbacks
The Punic Wars (264-146BC) sprang from a mighty power struggle between two ancient civilisations – the trading empire of Carthage and the military confedoration of Rome. It was a period of astonishing human misfortune, lasting over a period of 118 years and resulting in the radical depletion of Rome’s population and resources and the complete …
History of Carthage – Wikipedia
The city of Carthage was founded in the 9th century BC on the coast of Northwest Africa, in what is now Tunisia, as one of a number of Phoenician settlements in the western Mediterranean created to facilitate trade from the city of Tyre on the coast of what is now Lebanon. The name of both the city and the wider republic that grew out of it, Carthage developed into a significant trading empire …
What if Carthage had won the Punic Wars? | LaptrinhX / News
He and his army won a succession of victories across the Italian peninsula only to be called back to Carthage before having the chance to take Rome itself. Many historians believe that if Hannibal had pressed on and taken Rome, the second Punic war would have swung heavily in favor of the Carthaginians. … The Punic wars would have ended early …
WI: Carthage wins the Punic Wars | alternatehistory.com
Carthage simply did not have the manpower to throw at the enemy. To make Carthage truly conquer Rome, you need more manpower for Carthage. Carthaginians relying on mercenaries was not just for fun, or sheer obstinacy. They needed mercenaries just to be able to field a reasonably large army. Jun 2, 2013.
Punic Wars – Definition, Who Fought & Who Won – HISTORY
The three Punic Wars between Carthage and Rome took place over nearly a century, beginning in 264 B.C. and ending with the destruction of Carthage in 146 B.C.
濫 Could Carthage have won the Punic Wars?
Could Carthage have won the Punic Wars? First Punic War : Yes. The FPW was mostly a naval war and Carthage was the main naval power of the Western Mediterranean at that time, Rome had no navy before the war , so Carthage could win this one by cutting off the Roman armies in Sicily from reinforcements from mainland Italy.
Could Carthage Have Won The Punic Wars? [Comprehensive Answer]
The FPW was mostly a naval war and Carthage was the main naval power of the Western Mediterranean at that time, Rome had no navy before the war , so Carthage could win this one by cutting off the Roman armies in Sicily from reinforcements from mainland Italy. Rome and Carthage fought the the three wars known as the Punic Wars because the first …
The Punic Wars: How did the Romans crush Carthage?
The Romans burned down the ruins of the city, Carthage was leveled to the ground, and cursed in a special ceremony, prohibiting its settlement. Thus, in 120 years, Rome crushed Carthage’s pursuits of domination. As it turned out, the Punic Wars marked the emergence of Roman imperial rule, which eventually swept the world.
Punic Wars – Wikipedia
The Punic Wars were a series of wars (taking place between 264 and 146 BC) that were fought between the Roman Republic and Ancient Carthage.. The First Punic War broke out on the island of Sicily in 264 BC. It was regarded as “the longest and most severely contested war in history” by the Ancient Greek historian Polybius. The fighting, which consisted predominantly of naval warfare, largely …
Could the Carthaginians have created a Mediterranean-wide empire if …
Depending on how Carthage won the Punic Wars and the future leaders of the nation, it is very difficult to predict what the Carthaginians would have done, but a Mediterranean empire seems likely, albeit looking much different then Rome’s. Phoenician language and Punic culture might have been ingrained in the west rather then Latin, and …
4 Reasons Hannibal Couldn’t Win the War for Carthage
Rome had won the first Punic War by simply outlasting the Carthaginians in men and resources. The Romans had a potential manpower pool of around 700,000 men and were determined to win total victory no matter the cost. … he could bring some of that 700,000 away from Rome and have them ally with Carthage. Ideally, the beating he would give to …
Punic Wars | Summary, Causes, Battles, & Maps | Britannica
Punic Wars, also called Carthaginian Wars, (264-146 bce), a series of three wars between the Roman Republic and the Carthaginian (Punic) empire, resulting in the destruction of Carthage, the enslavement of its population, and Roman hegemony over the western Mediterranean. The origin of these conflicts is to be found in the position which Rome acquired, about 275 bce, as leader and protector …
Resource
https://askinglot.com/could-carthage-have-won-the-punic-wars
https://classicalwisdom.com/culture/history/what-if-carthage-had-won-the-punic-wars/
https://www.reddit.com/r/history/comments/7928o0/could_carthage_have_won_the_punic_wars/
https://www.mindrevolt.org/what-if-carthage-won-punic-wars
https://www.quora.com/Could-the-Carthaginians-have-won-the-Punic-wars-against-Rome-What-mistakes-did-they-make-to-lose-them-the-war?share=1
https://blitarkab.go.id/ask/could-carthage-have-won-the-punic-wars
https://www.history.com/topics/ancient-history/punic-wars
https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/wi-carthage-wins-the-punic-wars.281498/
https://www.quora.com/What-would-the-world-look-like-today-if-Carthage-had-won-the-Punic-Wars?share=1
https://www.thecollector.com/the-punic-wars-how-did-the-romans-crush-carthage/
https://candana.mymom.info/could/could-carthage-have-won-the-punic-wars.php
https://www.warhistoryonline.com/ancient-history/ed-ok-4-reasons-hannibal-couldnt-win-war-carthage.html
https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/if-carthage-won-the-punic-wars.622453/
https://www.reddit.com/r/HistoryWhatIf/comments/5wc3by/what_if_carthage_won_the_punic_wars/
https://kosmossociety.chs.harvard.edu/the-punic-wars-part-iii-delenda-cartago-est/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancient_Carthage
https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/if-carthage-won-the-punic-wars.622453/page-2
http://alaosq.wol.airlinemeals.net/who-won-the-3rd-punic-war/
https://blogs.sites.post-gazette.com/the-fall-of-carthage-the-punic-wars-265-146bc-cassell-military-paperbacks-pdf
http://alamish.eon.airlinemeals.net/content-https-en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Carthage
https://laptrinhx.com/news/what-if-carthage-had-won-the-punic-wars-r7BlE4/
https://www.alternatehistory.com/forum/threads/wi-carthage-wins-the-punic-wars.281498/
https://www.history.com/topics/ancient-history/punic-wars
https://blitarkab.go.id/ask/could-carthage-have-won-the-punic-wars
https://candana.mymom.info/could/could-carthage-have-won-the-punic-wars.php
https://www.thecollector.com/the-punic-wars-how-did-the-romans-crush-carthage/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punic_Wars
https://classical-worlds.quora.com/Could-the-Carthaginians-have-created-a-Mediterranean-wide-empire-if-they-had-won-the-Punic-Wars?share=1
https://www.warhistoryonline.com/ancient-history/ed-ok-4-reasons-hannibal-couldnt-win-war-carthage.html
https://www.britannica.com/event/Punic-Wars